The Best Drugstore Non-Comedogenic Concealers

Best Drugstore Non-Comedogenic Concealers

We independently select and review the products we recommend. We may earn a small commission on purchases made through our affiliate links below. Learn more about how we review products and our sources of information.

People with oily and acne-prone skin are advised to go for oil-free, non-comedogenic concealers. But these concealers have gained a whole new level of importance. And that leaves you with a proper concealer you’re hoping to rely on for smooth under-eyes and flawless skin. Well, the best drugstore non-comedogenic concealers multi-task big time!

They cover up under-eye discolorations and imperfections without looking greasy. And they conceal skin imperfections without clogging your pores or worsening acne.

And lastly, if you’re relying on your concealer for your base makeup, whether to avoid mask acne or just to go for no-makeup makeup looks, you’ll be using a good amount of product. But these concealers are incredibly budget-friendly!

As long as you’re being responsible and you properly remove your makeup, there’s no need to shy away from high-coverage concealers just because you’re prone to breakouts. So chin up!

The Best Drugstore Non-Comedogenic Concealers

Whether you want to cover up dark circles, dark spots, or acne, find below the best non-comedogenic concealers you can grab from the drugstore.

Maybelline Fit Me Concealer

Maybelline Fit Me Concealer - best drugstore non-comedogenic concealers

Considering the shade range, the formula, the price, and the coverage, I can honestly say that this is the overall best non-comedogenic concealer you can find at the drugstore. It works on any skin type! But for oily and acne-prone skin, this oil-free and fragrance-free concealer is a must-have.

You can do your whole makeup without worrying about clogged pores. The coverage is medium but absolutely buildable. And the finish is natural. So it works great for covering under-eye discolorations as well as acne, dots, and spots on the face. Plus, because it’s so gentle, it’s also a great concealer for rosacea.

Shades: 18 Finish: Natural Coverage: Medium/High Size: 0.23 oz

Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer

Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Concealer

Maybelline also has this oil-free non-comedogenic concealer. It comes with a sponge applicator tip and applies wet but dries down to a soft skin-like finish.

But it provides a little less coverage than Fit Me Concealer. If you’re looking for something light just for the under-eye area, try this one.

Shades: 18 Finish: Natural Coverage: Medium Size: 0.2 oz

Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Concealer

Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Concealer  - best drugstore non-comedogenic concealers

Full coverage doesn’t always translate to the best coverage. If you’re looking for something light coverage with a very natural finish, you can try this one. It’s for freshening up, giving your under-eyes some light, and subtly covering up redness and discolorations on the face.

The stick concealer is oil-free and simply hydrates and plumps up the skin. It has a hydrating core, not like a balm though, but like an eye serum, to infuse the skin with hyaluronic acid. Basically, it’s perfect for no-makeup makeup days when you want the most natural-looking finish.

Shades: 5 Finish: Natural Coverage: Light Size: 0.12 oz

Almay Clear Complexion Concealer

Almay Clear Complexion Concealer  - best drugstore non-comedogenic concealers

This is for concealing blemishes on the face. It contains our favorite active ingredient, so you won’t be able to use it to conceal your under-eyes. But it’s going to make life so much easier. If you’re actively dealing with red, inflamed acne that’s hard to treat and conceal, this one got your back. The concealer is made with salicylic acid with a concentration of 2%.

So you can treat acne, prevent it, and conceal it at the same time. It has a very creamy texture and applies super easily. The medium coverage is buildable too. If you’re already using an acne treatment as part of your skincare routine, be aware. Because too much salicylic acid can cause dryness and flakiness. The drugstore concealer is non-comedogenic, budget-friendly, fragrance-free, cruelty-free, and clean as a whistle.

Shades: 6 Finish: Matte Coverage: Medium Size: 0.18 oz

Colourpop Pretty Fresh Hyaluronic Creamy Concealer

Colourpop Pretty Fresh Hyaluronic Creamy Concealer  - best drugstore non-comedogenic concealers

This non-comedogenic concealer is full-coverage and long-lasting. It’ll smooth out the skin under the eyes and on the face. So you can either go without wearing foundation or use it to maximize your foundation coverage. The oil-free concealer is formulated with hydrating hyaluronic acid and coconut water.

So no congestion, clogged pores, or acne. Additionally, if you generally have oily skin, not just on the T-zone, you may be prone to milia on the face or under the eyes. So opting for a non-comedogenic formulation like this one will make sure you don’t get any milia.

Shades: 30 Finish: Natural Coverage: High Size: 0.30 oz

The Ordinary Concealer

The Ordinary Concealer  - best drugstore non-comedogenic concealers

The general belief around coverage is that the higher the coverage, the more likely it is to be comedogenic. And this right here is the perfect exception. This ridiculously affordable, pleasantly creamy, and satisfyingly high-coverage concealer is amazing for oily and acne-prone skin types.

The consistency is really rich. So it cancels out hyperpigmentation under the eyes, and redness around the nose, and covers up acne on the face really well. But it’s oil-free, so it will not worsen acne or cause blemishes. And there is a ton of shades to choose from no matter your skin tone!

Shades: 6 Finish: Natural Coverage: High Size: 0.2 oz

Nyx HD Photogenic Liquid Concealer

Nyx HD Photogenic Concealer Wand

Even though this is not oil-free and it’s actually pretty creamy, this is one of the best drugstore concealers you can get your hands on for super smooth, flawless under-eyes. Because it gets tricky to find a concealer that’s non-comedogenic, full coverage, affordable, and comes in a ton of shades.

So if oil-free is not a must, try this. It’s very rich and goes on smoothly. The high coverage, non-comedogenic formula neutralizes any under-eye discolorations, softens the visibility of under-eye wrinkles, and covers up any skin imperfections on the face too.

Shades: 23 Finish: Natural Coverage: High Size: 0.11 oz

Quick Tip: Another non-comedogenic concealer with long-lasting coverage and with waterproof formula is L’Oreal Infallible Full Wear Concealer. It’ll give you flawless skin and smooth under-eyes all day long. So if you need something matte, transfer-proof, and waterproof, try L’Oreal.

So these are some of the best drugstore non-comedogenic concealers that work. Remember, if you don’t properly remove your makeup, using non-comedogenic products won’t do much.

Read Next: The Best Concealer Alternatives

About The Author

Scroll to Top