Mascara Cocktailing: How to Layer Mascara

How To Layer Mascara

We independently select and review the products we recommend. We may earn a small commission on purchases made through our affiliate links below. Learn more about how we review products and our sources of information.

The motive behind layering mascara is usually about achieving voluminous and lengthy lashes. Personally, I’m up for anything that distracts people from my signature Turkish nose. My gigantic sniffer has been the driving force behind my mascara application experiments.

I’ve tried different types of mascaras, waterproof, regular, and fiber -all for the sake of achieving long, thick eyelashes. I can confidently say that mascara layering is the best way to achieve that fluttery look.

If you’re on the lookout for a way to get that faux lashes effect, keep reading to learn how to layer mascara.

What Is Mascara Layering?

Also known as mascara cocktailing, mascara layering is applying different mascaras with different benefits to achieve maximum length, curl, or volume.

Mascara layering is usually done by layering two different mascaras. So you don’t need more than that. The most important thing is using mascaras with different benefits.

For example, you can layer a lengthening mascara with a volumizing one. You can also try a curling mascara with a volumizing one. It’s all up to your preference.

The most important benefit of layering different mascaras is to get more benefits than you’d get from using a single mascara. Realistically speaking, a single mascara can’t give you length, volume, and curl but two mascaras can.

If you’ve perfected your mascara application and are ready to take your eye makeup game to a whole new level, find below a step-by-step guide for how to layer mascara.

How to Layer Mascara

1. Comb and Curl Your Lashes

This step is optional but using an eyelash curler or a lash comb is always helpful when you want to improve the results you get from your mascara. So if you prefer, start by curling your lashes, and combing them. You can even use an eyelash primer.

2. Choose Your First Mascara

Your first mascara is all about separating the lashes, defining them, and curling them a little. For this, you need a mascara that is not waterproof and that has a very thin brush.

These types of mascara wands help reach every single lash and brush them. I used Benefit’s Bad Gal Volumizing Mascara because that’s the one with the thinnest brush I currently have.

Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG! Volumizing Mascara - How To Layer Mascara
Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG! Volumizing Mascara

3. Remove the Excess

Before applying your first base, remove the excess mascara from the tip of the wand, which ends up in all the wrong places and contributes to clumping. Also, scrape the whole brush against the tip of the tube.

Remember, the first step is all about definition and kind of revealing what we’re dealing with. So there’s no need to go heavy just yet. The best way to avoid clumping when layering mascara is to get rid of the excess and go very light.

4. Apply First Mascara

Apply your base mascara starting from the bottom of your lashes and lift them up. Wiggle the wand at the base and sweep the mascara upward to the tip of the lashes. Apply as many coats as you like.

As this is your first layer, you don’t need to overdo it, which can lead to clumping. Make sure you also apply the mascara on those tiny lashes on the inner and outer corners.

5. Wait Between Layers

You need to wait a little bit between layering different mascaras to avoid that messy, clumpy look. After layering your base mascara, wait 30 or 60 seconds, depending on how fast your mascara dries.

If the first base dries completely, it’s going to be difficult to apply a different mascara on top of it. If you don’t wait long enough, then you’ll be mixing mascaras and won’t be able to achieve the best results. So make sure your lashes are damp enough to go over with the second mascara.

6. Choose Your Second Mascara

Your second mascara is the star of the show. For longer-lasting results, consider using waterproof mascara for this step. Depending on your lash goals, try mascara cocktailing with a volumizing mascara or a thickening one.

This is your top mascara. So it’s here to stay. I used the Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara. It’s perfect for volume all thanks to its hourglass-shaped wand.

Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara - How To Layer Mascara
Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara

7. Comb Lashes Between Layers

If you see any clumping or mascara flakes between layering, just use your mascara comb and go over the lashes to clean those up between each step. This prevents mascara clumping but also allows you to layer your mascaras evenly.

8. Layer Second Mascara

Start layering your second mascara by going over your eyelashes. Apply your mascara from the lash roots toward the tip of the lashes by wiggling the wand from left to right.

Go back and forth until you achieve the desired effect. As you’ve already touched the short lashes on the inner corners of the eyes with your base mascara, you only need to focus on the center now. Let your mascara dry and you’re done!

9. Bottom Lashes are Optional

Applying mascara on lower lashes is optional but you can comb them for some definition. You can also just touch the tips of the lower lashes with the tip of the mascara wand. Avoid layering multiple coats of mascara on bottom lashes as it can create a heavy look.

So this is what mascara layering, or mascara cocktailing, is and how you can try it to achieve long, and voluminous lashes. Keep experimenting with different formulas until you’re happy with your results.

Scroll to Top